This is the first of two articles on the topic of planar
magnetics. In this first part, a general overview of this
technology is presented to acquaint the reader with
these construction concepts.
Not long ago, an eye-catching advertisement
appeared in Electronic Products magazine. What made
the photo in this advertisement so notable was the presence
in it of a large towering magnetic assembly sitting
in the rear section of a densely populated computer
board, surrounded by numerous surface-mounted IC
chips and other miniature omponents. Figure 1 is
a reproduction of that photo.
While the amusement purpose of the advertisement
was to encourage readers to visit the magazine's
web site, it was visual evidence for many of
us working in the magnetics industries today of the
way users and system engineers often view power
magnetics. The physical size of these components
is not the only reason that power magnetics are
often viewed as "necessary-but-evil" parts in many
designs. Other reasons include high costs to manufacture
and assemble. In addition, they can and
do add significant weight to the power supply of
an system.
Thinking Thin….
To reduce the size and cost problems mentioned
earlier, designers are now turning to new assembly
design techniques for power magnetic components.
These techniques revolve around the use of lowheight
magnetic cores and windings that do not require
mounting bobbins. Figure 2 is an illustration of these
new planar construction methods for circular ("potcore-
like") and rectangular ("box-core-like") magnetic
assembles.
In the circular case in this figure, the windings are
realized using printed-circuit-board (PCB) assembly
methods while, in the case of the rectangular E-E or
E-I core assembly shown, the winding(s) could be
made from flat coils of formed wire. In either case,
there is no wiring "bobbin" in either assembly
approach. Figure 3 is a photo of some PCB windings
used in a typical planar E-E core magnetic assembly.
Looking at the circular core-and-winding arrangement
depicted in Figure 2, it is easy to see why planar
magnetic construction approaches can be inexpensive,
requiring no significant labor talent for assembly nor
special assembly equipment. Because the windings are
"built" using PCB design techniques, turns positioning
are precise and consistent, yielding magnetic designs
with highly controllable "parasitics" (e.g., winding resistances, leakage inductances and capacitances).
As far as component height is concerned, a magnetic
in a medium power application today is considered a
planar design if its height dimension is on the order of
0.5 inches or less. For power magnetics in modern
telecommunications rack-mounted power supplies, the
height requirement can be even lower, on the order of
0.25 inches!
On the other hand, low-profile power magnetics often
have larger surface areas than their wired, high-profilecounterparts,
requiring more packaging space as a
result. However, larger surface areas gives the user
more effective unit areas for cooling the part, which
can be an important advantage in those cases where
the magnetics in question are used in high-power
applications.
Most planar magnetics assemblies today utilize
power core materials of the manganese-zinc
(Mn-Zn) or nickel-zinc (Ni-Zn) ceramic varieties,
with the Mn-Zn material being the most
popular today in applications where power-processing
frequencies are less than 2 MHz. Above
this frequency, the Ni-Zn material becomes more
efficient, as its resistivity is several orders or
magnitude larger than Mn-Zn. Because of the
ease of manufacture, ferrite cores can be made in
many shapes and sizes and, for this reason, is the primary
core material for planar magnetics designs. The
only disadvantage of ferrite material is the relatively
low value of saturation flux density when compared
to other core material types available today. |